Allspice vs. Clove, Nutmeg, and Mace

Pick your champion:

In this corner, we have Candidate 1

200. grams Pastry Flour (1/2 Cake and 1/2 AP = Pastry)
30.0 grams Salt
7.50 grams MSG
4.00 grams Black Pepper (1/2 fine, 1/2 medium coarse)
2.00 grams White Pepper
1.25 grams Coriander Seed
1.00 grams Allspice
1.00 grams Ginger
1.00 grams Sage
1.00 grams Savory
0.50 grams Anise Seed
0.38 grams Cayenne Pepper
0.13 grams Oregano
0.13 grams Garlic Powder

And in this corner, we have Candidate 2

200. grams Pastry Flour (1/2 Cake and 1/2 AP = Pastry)
30.0 grams Salt
7.50 grams MSG
4.00 grams Black Pepper (1/2 fine, 1/2 medium coarse)
2.00 grams White Pepper
1.25 grams Coriander Seed
1.00 grams Ginger
1.00 grams Sage
1.00 grams Savory
0.38 grams Cayenne Pepper
0.25 grams Nutmeg
0.21 grams Clove
0.13 grams Mace
0.13 grams Oregano
0.13 grams Garlic Powder